Home β€Ί Snacks & Chips β€Ί Lay's New York Reuben
πŸ₯ͺ
AISLE 2 Β· SNACKS & CHIPS

Lay's New York Reuben

by Lay's
2015 – 2015 GONE FOREVER

Gone. Lay's kept only the winner on shelves after voting closed in October 2015. It said it would look for chances to bring the runners-up back for limited runs, but New York Reuben has not returned.

Last verified Nov 12, 2026

A deli sandwich ground into chip dust: the Reuben as a potato chip, one of four finalists in Lay's 2015 Do Us a Flavor contest. America voted for biscuits and gravy instead, and the Reuben went back to the deli.

🧾 One more thingThe flavor was dreamed up by Jeff Solensky of DuBois, Pennsylvania, who took home $50,000 as a runner-up. The winner's prize was $1 million or 1% of its flavor's net sales, whichever was higher.

Filed under: Snacks & Chips Β· the ’00s & later

πŸ“œ The full story

Lay's Do Us a Flavor contest asked the public to invent a potato chip. Entrants sent in a flavor name, up to three ingredients, a chip style and a short story, and in 2015 the theme was American places. Lay's said it received millions of entries. A panel picked four, and on July 15 the company announced them, with the singer Nick Lachey turning up at each finalist's home to deliver the news.

New York Reuben was the entry of Jeff Solensky, who helped manage a restaurant in DuBois, Pennsylvania. He had grown up on Long Island, and his story was about eating Reubens with his mother at New York delis before Broadway shows. His chip went up against Southern Biscuits and Gravy, Wavy West Coast Truffle Fries and Kettle Cooked Greektown Gyro.

All four reached stores on July 27, 2015, the day voting opened. People could vote once a day on the contest site, with a hashtag on Twitter or Instagram, or by text. Voting closed on October 18, and on October 21 Lay's announced that biscuits and gravy had won. Its creator, a travel agent from Indiana, received the grand prize of $1 million or one percent of the flavor's net sales, whichever was greater. Solensky and the other two runners-up received $50,000 each.

Only the winner stayed on sale. A Frito-Lay marketing executive said the company would look for opportunities to bring the runner-up flavors back for limited appearances, and for the Reuben none has come. Lay's never published a last day for it. In January 2023 a writer for The Nosher, a Jewish food site, addressed an open letter to the company asking for a successor, and suggested a few deli flavors of her own, pastrami with mustard among them.

πŸ“… Timeline

  1. 2015Frito-Lay unveiled the four Do Us a Flavor finalists on July 15.
  2. 2015New York Reuben went on sale nationwide on July 27, the day voting opened.
  3. 2015Voting closed October 18, and on October 21 Lay's named Southern Biscuits and Gravy the winner.
  4. 2023The Nosher, a Jewish food site, published an open letter asking Lay's to bring the flavor back.

❓ People also ask

Did Lay's really make Reuben chips?

Yes. Lay's New York Reuben was a 2015 Do Us a Flavor finalist, sold nationwide for the voting period that summer and fall.

What beat Lay's New York Reuben?

Southern Biscuits and Gravy, which won the 2015 vote. The other finalists were Wavy West Coast Truffle Fries and Kettle Cooked Greektown Gyro.

Who invented Lay's New York Reuben?

Jeff Solensky of DuBois, Pennsylvania, who helped manage a local restaurant. He grew up on Long Island and said the idea came from eating Reubens with his mother at New York delis before Broadway shows.

Will Lay's bring New York Reuben back?

Nothing has been announced. When the contest ended, a Frito-Lay marketing executive said the company would look for opportunities to bring runner-up flavors back for limited runs; that has not happened for the Reuben.

How did the Do Us a Flavor vote work?

Fans could vote once a day on the contest website, by hashtag on Twitter and Instagram, or by text message, from July 27 to October 18, 2015.

🧾 Sources

  1. PepsiCo, Lay's Potato Chips Unveils The Four Finalists Vying For $1 Million Grand Prize In The "Do Us A Flavor" Contest (2015)
  2. PepsiCo, Lay's Potato Chips Announces Lay's Southern Biscuits And Gravy Flavored Chips As 2015 "Do Us A Flavor" Contest Winner (2015)
  3. CNBC, Lay's four new potato chip flavors put to the test (2015)
  4. Snack & Bakery, Frito-Lay announces 2015 'Do Us A Flavor' contest winner (2015)
  5. My Jewish Learning (The Nosher), Dear Lay's: Give Us A Replacement For Your New York Reuben Chips (2023)
πŸ•―οΈ Shoppers also mourned