Toast-Yay!
Gone. In January 2025 Girl Scouts of the USA announced that Toast-Yay! and S'mores would retire after that season. It is not in the 2026 lineup, whose only new cookie, Exploremores, is unrelated.
Last verified Nov 1, 2026
A Girl Scout cookie shaped like a tiny slice of French toast, iced on one side and stamped with the trefoil on the other. It lasted five seasons, which is four more than most breakfast-themed desserts get.
Filed under: Snacks & Chips · the ’00s & later
📅 Timeline
- 2020On August 18, Girl Scouts of the USA announced Toast-Yay!, a French toast-inspired cookie dipped in icing, for select areas in the 2021 season.
- 2021The cookie went on sale in councils supplied by ABC Bakers, the only licensed baker that made it.
- 2025On January 7, Girl Scouts of the USA announced that Toast-Yay! and Girl Scout S'mores would be retired at the close of the 2025 cookie season.
- 2026The 2026 lineup, announced in September 2025, added the Exploremores sandwich cookie and did not include Toast-Yay!.
❓ People also ask
Why was Toast-Yay! discontinued?
Girl Scouts of the USA gave no cookie-specific reason. A spokesperson said the organization routinely reevaluates its lineup to make room for new cookies, and neither Toast-Yay! nor S'mores was among its best sellers.
Was Toast-Yay! vegan?
Yes. VegNews covered it as a new vegan cookie in December 2020, and ABC Bakers listed it among its cookies made with vegan ingredients, while noting it could be run on equipment shared with dairy products.
What did Toast-Yay! look like?
It was shaped like a slice of toast, dipped in icing on one side and stamped with the Girl Scouts trefoil on top.
🧾 Sources
- 6abc Philadelphia, Girl Scouts debut new French toast-inspired cookie (2020)
- VegNews, Girl Scouts' new vegan cookie is inspired by French toast (2020)
- CNN via KRDO, The Girl Scouts are retiring two cookie flavors after this season (2025)
- FOX 6 Milwaukee, Girl Scouts drop brand-new cookie for 2026 (2025)