Home β€Ί Candy & Gum β€Ί Hershey's Carb Alternatives
πŸ“‰
AISLE 4 Β· CANDY & GUM

Hershey's Carb Alternatives

by Hershey's
2004 – 2004 GONE FOREVER

Gone. Hershey's archives record the Carb Alternatives line as introduced in July 2004 and discontinued in December 2004. Hershey's separate Sugar Free line, launched in 2003, is a different product.

Last verified Nov 11, 2026

Kisses, Kit Kats, Reese's cups and almond bars remade for the Atkins era, with artificial sweeteners standing in for half the sugar carbs. They arrived in summer 2004 at the peak of the low-carb craze and were gone by Christmas.

🧾 One more thingThe whole line lasted about six months. Hershey's own archives record it as introduced in July 2004 and discontinued that December, as the low-carb boom that created it ran out.

Filed under: Candy & Gum Β· the ’00s & later

πŸ“œ The full story

In 2004 it seemed that every food company in America was being asked what it was doing about carbohydrates. Nearly half the exhibitors at that June's All Candy Expo showed something low-carb. Hershey already had a sugar-free line, introduced the year before, and in March it added 1 Gram Sugar Carb bars for dieters following the rules strictly.

Carb Alternatives was the gentler option. Rather than invent a diet bar, Hershey took four of its best-known products, Kisses, Kit Kat, Reese's Peanut Butter Cups and Hershey's with Almonds, and replaced part of the sugar with artificial sweeteners to cut the 'sugar carbs' in half. Samples were at a Chicago trade show in May, and on a July earnings call the company said the launch was going ahead even though the craze was reported to be levelling off.

The reviews were lukewarm. Writing in the Christian Science Monitor that September, the candy writer Steve Almond allowed that they were better than most diet candy but said they still came off as frauds. The larger problem was the calendar. Growth in low-carb food sales, above 100 percent at the start of 2004, had fallen to about 6 percent by the third quarter.

Hershey's own archive records the line as discontinued in December 2004, roughly six months after it arrived. The company made no announcement that we could find. Its annual report for 2005 lists neither Carb Alternatives nor the 1 Gram bars, while the older Sugar Free candies are still there. The following year the trade press was already describing low-carb chocolate as a short-lived success.

πŸ“… Timeline

  1. 2003Hershey introduced its Hershey's and Reese's Sugar Free candies in March, a separate line that outlasted the low-carb craze.
  2. 2004In May Hershey handed out individually wrapped Carb Alternative candies at the Food Marketing Institute trade show in Chicago.
  3. 2004The line went on sale nationally in the summer, in July by Hershey's records, as Kisses, Kit Kat, Reese's Peanut Butter Cups and Hershey's with Almonds, each with 50 percent fewer sugar carbs.
  4. 2004Hershey's archives record Carb Alternatives as discontinued in December.
  5. 2005By the third quarter of 2004 growth in low-carb food sales had fallen from more than 100 percent to about 6 percent, figures published in January 2005.

❓ People also ask

What were Hershey's Carb Alternatives?

Low-carb versions of Kisses, Kit Kat, Reese's Peanut Butter Cups and Hershey's with Almonds, sweetened partly with artificial sweeteners.

Is this the same as Hershey's Sugar Free?

No. Hershey's Sugar Free candies launched in 2003 and are a separate line. Carb Alternatives lasted only from July to December 2004.

Why were Carb Alternatives discontinued?

Hershey gave no public reason that we could find. The market did the explaining: growth in sales of carb-conscious foods fell from 105.5 percent in the first quarter of 2004 to 6.1 percent in the third, according to ACNielsen figures reported by Supermarket News.

Were Carb Alternatives the same as the 1 Gram Sugar Carb bars?

No. Hershey had two low-carb lines in 2004. The 1 Gram Sugar Carb bars were the strict version; Carb Alternatives was pitched, in Candy Industry's words, at people wanting a more moderate carb reduction in candy they already knew.

How sure is the December 2004 end date?

It rests on one source, the chronology kept by the Hershey Community Archives. Hershey's annual report for 2004 still listed the line; the report for 2005 did not. So it was certainly gone within a year, and December 2004 is the archive's date.

🧾 Sources

  1. Candy Industry, Candy for Contemporary Consumers (2004)
  2. The Christian Science Monitor, No sugarcoating the bad news (2004)
  3. Hershey Community Archives, Hershey's Carb Alternative Chocolate Candy introduced (chronology entry)
  4. CBS News (AP), Food Companies On Low-Carb Diet (2004)
  5. Reuters via Fox News, S'Mores Sweetens Hershey Foods' Profit (2004)
  6. Supermarket News, Down, Not Out (2005)
  7. SEC EDGAR, The Hershey Company Form 10-K (fiscal 2005) (2006)
πŸ•―οΈ Shoppers also mourned