🍞
AISLE 2 · SNACKS & CHIPS
Toast-Yay!
by Girl Scouts
Gone. In January 2025 Girl Scouts of the USA announced that Toast-Yay! and S'mores would retire after that season. It is not in the 2026 lineup, whose only new cookie, Exploremores, is unrelated.
A Girl Scout cookie shaped like a tiny slice of French toast, iced on one side and stamped with the trefoil on the other. It lasted five seasons, which is four more than most breakfast-themed desserts get.
🧾 One more thingIt was vegan, and only ABC Bakers made it, so councils supplied by Little Brownie Bakers, the other licensed bakery, never sold it at all. Girl Scouts announced it in August 2020, in time for the 2021 season.
Filed under: Snacks & Chips · the ’00s & later
🕯️ Shoppers also mourned