
Thingamajig
Gone. Hershey never announced an end. Its annual 10-K filings listed Thingamajig through the one filed in February 2013 and not after, so 2013 is the documented end; fan accounts often say 2012. Whatchamacallit's 2021 Whozeewhatzit is a different bar.
Last verified Nov 11, 2026
Whatchamacallit's sibling with the even vaguer name: real chocolate, cocoa crisps and peanut butter. It started as a 2009 limited edition, came back, made it onto Hershey's product list, and then simply stopped being mentioned.
Filed under: Candy & Gum Β· the β00s & later
π The full story
Whatchamacallit had never had a companion bar. In early 2009 Hershey gave it one and reached one shelf further down the list of words for things you can't name. Thingamajig swapped the original's peanut-flavored crisps for cocoa crisps and its caramel for peanut butter, wrapped the result in a red wrapper, and sold it as a limited edition.
Reviewers got to it within weeks. The A.V. Club ran the two bars head to head in February and gave the win to the original, finding the newcomer softer and more chocolatey. Others noticed that it was made with real cocoa butter, which Whatchamacallit's coating was not, and regretted that it was only temporary.
Hershey was pleased enough to repeat it. A sales sheet sent to retailers called the 2009 bar a success that had helped lift Whatchamacallit sales by a fifth, said shoppers wanted it back, and offered a second run from September to December 2010 in a shared display with its older sibling. Starting with the annual report filed in February 2011, Thingamajig was listed among the products Hershey sells in the United States.
It stayed on that list for three filings. The report filed in February 2014 names Whatchamacallit and not Thingamajig, and Hershey never said anything about why. Fans tend to date the end to 2012, which the filings do not rule out. When Hershey next extended the family, in 2021, it used a third name, Whozeewhatzit, for a different recipe.
π Timeline
- 2009Thingamajig was on sale by late February as a nationally distributed limited-edition Hershey bar.
- 2010Hershey offered it to retailers again for a second window, September 3 to December 3, packed alongside Whatchamacallit.
- 2011Hershey's 10-K filed in February listed Thingamajig among its US products.
- 2013Hershey's 10-K filed in February 2013 was the last to list Thingamajig; it was gone from the 2014 filing.
- 2021Hershey added a different sibling bar, Whozeewhatzit, to the Whatchamacallit family.
β People also ask
What was in a Thingamajig bar?
Chocolate, cocoa crisps and peanut butter. Its sibling Whatchamacallit uses peanut-flavored crisps and caramel.
When was Thingamajig discontinued?
There was no announcement. Hershey stopped listing it in its annual reports after early 2013. Fan sources often say 2012.
When did Thingamajig come out?
Early 2009. The A.V. Club ran a taste test against Whatchamacallit on February 24 that year, using a bar bought at a Chicago Walgreens.
Did Thingamajig ever come back?
At least once. A Hershey sales sheet for retailers offered it again from September 3 to December 3, 2010, in a display holding 36 Thingamajig and 36 Whatchamacallit bars. After that it appeared in Hershey's annual reports for three years.
Was Thingamajig popular?
Hershey said so. The same sales sheet called the 2009 bar a success, credited it with helping lift Whatchamacallit sales 20 percent, and said 92 percent of the consumer comments it received were positive. Those are the company's own claims to retailers.
π§Ύ Sources
- SEC EDGAR, The Hershey Company Form 10-K (fiscal year ended December 31, 2012) (2013)
- SEC EDGAR, The Hershey Company Form 10-K (fiscal 2013) (2014)
- The Hershey Company (copy hosted on Yumpu), THINGAMAJIG was a successful Limited Edition bar (trade sell sheet) (2010)
- The A.V. Club / The Takeout, Taste Test: Thingamajig Vs. Whatchamacallit (2009)
- waldo.jaquith.org, Candy Review: Hershey's Thingamajig, Wildly Cherry M&Ms. (2009)