Mr. Pibb

by Coca-Cola

1972 – 2001 IT CAME BACK

Back — sort of. The Mr. Pibb name returned in October 2025 with a revamped, more-caffeinated formula, rolling out wider through 2026 (plus vanilla and peach spin-offs). It replaces Pibb Xtra, but purists note it isn't the exact pre-2001 recipe.

Coke's spicy answer to Dr Pepper spent three decades as the pepper soda you got when the restaurant didn't carry the real thing — and millions loved it anyway. In 2001 Coca-Cola quietly killed the original, replacing it with a cinnamon-forward remix called Pibb Xtra, and the 'Mr.' vanished from shelves for 24 years.

🧾 One more thingIt was born in 1972 as 'Peppo' and renamed Mr. Pibb within months because Dr Pepper sued. The 2025 resurrection was also lawyer-driven: a Texas court ruling ended Coca-Cola's role distributing Dr Pepper at fountains, so Coke needed its own pepper soda back on the marquee.

Filed under: Drinks & Sodas · the ’70s & earlier

🎲 Remember another one 🛒 Test your memory

🕯️ Shoppers also mourned